This posting is the first of at least two I will do on the Convento. In this one I will show you its exterior features and explain how it came to be built on this particular spot. I will also relate the story of Diego de Landa, the Franciscan friar who directed the construction of the massive facility, but who is also infamous for his treatment of the indigenous population of Yucatan. In subsequent postings I will take you inside to see some of the art work dating to the colonial period.
Overview
Location of Convento San Antonio de Padua. The Convento stands on a raised platform on the south side of Izamal's main plaza. The rectangular structure in the lower left quadrant of the photo is the Convento's atrium. The platform was originally the base of a great pyramid called Papolchac ("House of Heads and Lightning")*. Today's plaza is part of the the ancient city's much larger plaza, which was surrounded on all sides by pyramids. On the south was Papolchac, on the west Ka'bul, and on the east Itzamatul. Two blocks to the north is Kinich Kakmó. To view the ruins of the last three, see Parts 1 and 2 of this series.*Maya Missions, Exploring Colonial Yucatan, p.199, Richard and Rosalind Perry, España Press, pub. 2002.
Scale model of the Convento. The atrium has three entrances. The long staircase in the west side was for the Maya, who climbed it painfully on their knees as an act of penance. The north and south sides have ramps that were used by the colonial elite. The inside dimensions of the atrium measure 122m x 61m (400ft x 200ft), enough space for a modern football field. The entrance to the church is on the east side of the atrium, under a large campanario (belfry). To the left of the church are two cloisters, where the friars lived and worked. On the church's right side is an open chapel reserved for services for the indigenous people.
The Papolchac pyramid and its associated structures (except for the platform) were completely demolished by the friars who built the Convento. Their leader, Diego de Landa, described the Papolchac pyramid as a structure "of astonishing height and beauty...and on top a beautiful chapel of finely worked stone."* Since it was dedicated to Itzamná, the Sky God, he and his fellow friars felt no compunction about destroying it. Demolishing native temples and using their materials to build Catholic churches was all part of the Spiritual Conquest and the Franciscans went about it with great zeal.
*Time Among the Maya, p.345, Ronald Wright, Grove Press, NY. pub. 2000.
The Franciscan friar Diego de Landa, portrayed in a 16th century painting. Diego de Landa is a controversial figure today, as he was also in his own time. He was born in 1524 in Cifuentes, Guadalajara, Spain. In 1541, at the age of 16, he entered the Franciscan Order at the Convento de San Juan de los Reyes in Toledo, Spain. Almost immediately, he was recognized as a very talented and energetic young man. He was an excellent linguist, something that caught the attention of Nicolas Albalete a Franciscan friar who had recently returned from evangelizing in Mexico and knew that language was a key to success.
Fra. Albalete persuaded Landa to go to Yucatan to help with the Spiritual Conquest, along with five other Franciscans. When they arrived at Izamal in 1549, Landa immediately set about learning the Yucatec Maya dialect. He was soon proficient enough to improve upon a Maya grammar book written by an earlier Franciscan. Landa was fearless and set off alone on journeys throughout the Yucatan Peninsula, often to areas still hostile to the Spanish. He traveled in the Franciscan style, descalzo (barefoot) and dressed only in a coarse woolen habit that was belted with a simple rope.
Exterior Features of the Convento
Diego de Landa had many adventures during his solitary travels. In the process, he learned a great deal about the Maya. He once entered the remote village of Zitaz, whose population had never encountered a Spaniard. Seeing a crowd of 300 armed men, he approached and glimpsed a youth tied to a pole and about to be sacrificed. Landa strode forward through the startled crowd and released the victim. Turning, he denounced the practice of human sacrifice. Then, in their own language, he started preaching the Christian gospel. His audacity and strangeness overawed the Maya, who gazed in wonder at this apparition.
The northwest corner of the atrium wall. The west wall is supported by a series of buttresses. Along the top of the wall are pointed white merlons, a decorative feature popular in colonial times. The north, west, and south walls have arched windows that allow a view of other nearby structures and the plazas on each of these sides. The major structures of the Convento, including the church and the cloisters, are all on the east side of the atrium.
Landa was only 25 years old when he arrived in Izamal. In 1533, only four years later, he was appointed custodio (head) of the monastery. This meteoric rise at such a youthful age indicates the high regarded in which he was held. However, other factors may have helped, including a scarcity of friars willing to go to Yucatan and a high mortality rate among those who did. One of Landa's chief projects during his time as custodio was the construction of the Convento San Antonio de Padua. Begun in 1549 and finished in 1561, it was completed in an extraordinarily short time, largely through the forced labor of 6000 Maya workers.
Horse-drawn carriages haul tourists along the north side of the Convento. Carole can be seen against the wall between the carriages. We have encountered, and occasionally utilized, carriages like this while visiting other Mexican cities, including Mérida, Yucatan's capital. The carriages and horses are often decorated in amusing ways, like the straw sombrero worn by the horse in front.
In 1562, shortly after the completion of the Convento, Diego de Landa was elected as Provincial Vicar of Yucatan and Guatamala. This meant that he became the deputy to the top leader of all the Franciscans in that broad geographical area. His completion of the vast Convento no doubt contributed to his elevation to such a high position. However, not everyone was pleased by the new Convento. Some found its size excessive.
In 1561, Francisco de Toral (1502-1571) was appointed Bishop of Yucatan. Also a Franciscan, he became one of Landa's severest critics. Speaking of the newly completed Convento, Bishop Toral said that "it is a fine thing to see and a scandal to permit it, for surely St. Francis (the founder of the Order) condemns it in his Rule." This would not be the last time that Toral found fault with Diego de Landa's approach to his work.
The Franciscans were the dominant evangelizing Order in Yucatan during this period and Landa's exalted position gave him great power. However the combination of this power with his energy and zeal soon got him into trouble and led to infamy that still continues after 500 years. In fairness to Landa, part of the problem was the whole Franciscan approach to the Spiritual Conquest. They sometimes lacked respect for Maya traditions and always abhorred their religious beliefs, which they considered "devil worship". While they were prepared to be benevolent, they basically saw the Maya as children needing strong parenting.
Viewing the Maya as children, the Franciscans worked to protect them from theft, abuse and violence by the secular Spaniards. At the same time, they acted as stern fathers who exercised control over every aspect of the native peoples' lives. After persuading large numbers to convert, the friars began to discover that their efforts had often not produced true believers. In fact, Maya traditions and religious beliefs dated back several millennia and shaped their whole view of the world. They simply incorporated the Christian god into their vast pantheon of deities, just one among many. This was unacceptable to the Franciscans.
By the time Landa was elected Provincial Vicar, reports had been accumulating about the continuation of the ancient practices, secretly in areas near Franciscan outposts and more openly in remote areas. As a class, the ah-kin (Maya priests) had been very powerful in pre-hispanic times and they bitterly resented the new regime and its overthrow of their status and power. Many Maya commoners went through the motions demanded by the friars, but then turned to the ah-kin and their old belief systems to hedge their bets. The Franciscans found this extremely frustrating. Some, including Landa, viewed it as a vast conspiracy.
One of the atrium's northside ramps. As you can see, these were not stairways, but smooth ramps, not unlike modern ramps for disabled people in wheelchairs. At the top of the initial stage, you turn and walk up in the opposite direction to the level of the arcade. In the upper left of the photo are some of the colonial-era arcades and portales that surround the plaza. In colonial times, these might have contained the townhomes of the Spanish elites. Colonial towns centered on plazas. The highest status people lived immediately around the plaza, with rings of increasingly lower status people out to the Maya areas on the fringes.
Fra. Pedro de Ciudad Rodrigo was the custodio of the monastery at Mani, 107km (67mi) southeast of Izamal. In 1561, he discovered evidence of a child's crucifixion near his monastery. According to one account, native leaders at the sacrifice said: "Let this child die crucified as did Jesus Christ, he who they say is our Lord, but we do not know if this is so." After crucifixion, the child's heart was be cut out in the ancient fashion and delivered to the ah-kin, who then dedicated it to the ancient gods. As horrifying as this seems to modern sensibilities, it was a practice dating back millennia.
Inside the Great Atrium
Landa was very disturbed by the discovery at Mani. Then, in 1562, two Maya youths from Mani discovered some idols and a skeleton in a cave. It is not clear that the skeleton was the result of a sacrifice, but Landa ordered an investigation. This resulted in the questioning and torture of a number of Maya who lived in or around Mani. Some confessed to performing rituals at the idols but later recanted, saying that their confessions were the result of the torture. However, the confessions convinced Landa that a huge network of underground apostates existed, led by local Maya leaders and ah-kin.
The atrium, looking toward the northwest corner. This view provides a sense of its great length. The place where I took this shot was only about 1/2 way down the east side. A total of 75 portales (arches) line the interior of the atrium. This is the largest number I have found in any single colonial-era building in Mexico.
Back in 1539, the first Bishop of Mexico, Juan de Zumárraga, met with the heads of the various evangelizing Orders, including the Franciscans. They were concerned about the slowness of evangelization and the fact that many converts soon revered to their old religions. They decided that missionaries could use "light punishments" to force conversions and to discourage relapses. After the discoveries at Mani in 1562, Landa decided to use this decision as the basis for launching an Inquisition.
Spanish Inquisitions were notoriously cruel and Landa's was no different. It lasted three months at Mani. According to witnesses, those being questioned were tied to whipping posts and lashed so that their bodies and skin were ripped and damaged. When it came time for punishment after their confessions, "there was no sound part on which they could be flogged." They also used a practice called "hoisting", in which victima were hung by their wrists so that their feet didn't touch the floor. Sometimes stones were tied to their feet to increase the pressure on the victims' wrists. While in this position they were lashed.
Landa focused most of his wrath on the traditional Maya leaders and the ah-kin. He felt the commoners had been misled by them and he held local elites primarily responsible for the backsliding. The methods he used to extract confessions and exact punishment were certainly appalling, but this was because he believed he had to destroy any remnant of the ancient Maya culture that might tempt them into further relapses. Consequently, he burned every statue, image, or artifact holding any possible religious significance.
He also destroyed every hieroglyphic document he could find. In Landa's own words, "We found a large number of books in these characters (hieroglyphs) and, as they contained nothing in which were not to be seen as superstition and lies of the devil, we burned them all, which they (the Maya) regretted to an amazing degree and which caused them much affliction." The books are called codices and only three still exist, along with part of one other. The libraries he destroyed contained thousands of years of history, mythology, and astronomical observations. It was an act of cultural genocide in which he was very thorough.
Many of Diego de Landa's contemporaries were appalled at his actions. In the 1580s, the Jesuit historian Jose de Acosta wrote that "our people, believing that all the Indian books were mere superstition, have destroyed a record of ancient and obscure matters from which we might have derived no little benefit. This stems from an ignorant zeal which, without either knowing or wishing to know the truth, asserts without evidence that everything about the Indians is the work of superstitions."
Francisco de Toral, Bishop of Yucatan from 1562 to 1570. When Toral heard about Landa's activities, he wrote a strong letter of protest to King Phillip II. The bishop charged that the Franciscan Vicar had conducted an illegal Inquisition and grossly abused the Maya. Landa soon returned to Spain to answer the charges. To support his case, he wrote the Relacion de las cosas de Yucatan (Account of the Affairs of Yucatan). What he composed was an extraordinary ethnographic study of Maya language, institutions, culture, history, politics and much else. It is still studied today.
The case dragged on until 1565, when Landa was finally acquitted of all charges. A couple of years after his acquittal, he returned to Yucatan as its new bishop, succeeding his great critic Bishop Toral, who abdicated his position in 1570. Landa served as Bishop of Yucatan until his death in 1579.
One modern historian states that 99% of what we know about the Maya culture in this period comes from Landa's Relacion. But, he also says that Landa destroyed 99% of what we might have known if we had access to the precious books that he turned to ashes.
This completes Part 3 of my series on Izamal. I hope you enjoyed it. If so, please leave any thoughts or questions in the Comments section below or email me directly. If you leave a question, please include your email address so that I may respond in a timely manner.
Hasta luego, Jim
















.jpg)
No comments:
Post a Comment
If your comment involves a question, please leave your email address so I can answer you. Thanks, Jim